10 Confessions & a Kiss – Chapter 1 by Katrina Joyner
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I promise to be brutally honest with my opinion, but it should not be taken as fact. Any reader should read it for themselves, before they decide if this book has any merit or not. Do not judge this book biased solely on my opinion. If you do, you might miss out on a great read. You never know. It could happen. My review may contain spoilers, but I really strive to be spoiler-free. This book was sent to my email address by the author with no strings attached. She noticed that I had read the first draft of her other graphic novel Heavenly Bride and sent it to me, thinking that I would enjoy this one as well. I do know this author by her work, but not personally. Therefore, I am not affiliated with this author or her publisher. I have no stake in the author’s endeavors and stand to gain nothing from giving a glowing review. So, without further ado, my review of the first chapter of 10 Confessions & A Kiss: Chapter One: The Bracelet.
1. Strong Main Character/ Female Heroine: Zoe is a strong and defiant character, but she is also self-centered. She is the “why me?” character that can get a bit annoying, so the reader is sort of happy, when she is cursed. Hopefully, it will knock some sense in her and make her look for love that is real, not superficial. 4 out of 5 stars
2. Strong Main Character / Male Hero: Zoe’s best friend….I do not remember, if the story ever mentions his name….I cannot see it anywhere. Anyways, I found him quite entertaining and gave the story a down-to-earth feel. 4 out of 5 stars
3. Strong Main Character / Evil Antagonist: The Bracelet, which does not make it much of a character. N/A
4. Strong Minor Characters: The only real minor characters is the gypsy lady and her son that works in a fortune tellers shop. There is not too much depth that goes into them, but this is only chapter one. 3 out of 5 stars
5. The Plot: The plot was interesting, but a bit predictable due to the title; however, the details that went into the plot were fresh and new to me. However, a girl gets cursed and must find true love and cannot see that her best friend loves her has been done before. 3 out of 5 stars
6. The Setting: Not much of a setting. It could be anywhere. I wish there were more scenery like in other graphic novels that I have read or at least a brief description of where this novel occurs. 3 out of 5 stars
7. The Dialogue: The character dialect is so much better in this story than in the Heavenly Bride, which is a very good thing. It is one of the story’s redeeming qualities. The witty, humorous banter between the two best friends kept me reading this short chapter. I want to read the next just to see what they will say next. 5 out of 5 stars
8. Engaging Surprises: No real surprises here, just funny details. I wish there were some surprising elements to this story. If the title were less telling, than it would have held a few surprises. 1 out of 5 stars
9. Climax: Really not much of a climax. By the title, one can pretty much tell that Zoe will be cursed, probably by a bracelet. Not a real surprise. I really wish that it was more of a surprise, because there would have been that climatic moment. It fell flat here. 1 out of 5 stars
10. Emotional Response: This story is not much of an emotional thing. It made me laugh, but that was about it. And smiles, never forget the smiles. The story is too short to really make you invested in the story and the characters, but it provided comical relief. 3 out of 5 stars
11. Ending: I feel like I want to read the second chapter to see how the story progresses. The ending leaves me wanting more, but not completely off my rocker need to read it. It is not overly compelling, but definitely something I would like to read in the future. I want to know, if the main character ever figures everything out. The ending is kind of funny and made for a pleasurable read that was relaxing instead of thought provoking. It was exactly what I needed at the time. 3 out of 5 stars
12. The Writing: The grammar in this story is so much better than in Heavenly Bride, which makes me think that she might have taken more time with this story than with the other one? I am not sure, but the writing is so much better. I actually think that she might be developing her own unique voice. She is definitely getting herself to stand out with her artwork. I get that writing may not be her thing, but I see a big improvement. If she paired herself with a different author to tell a story, we could see the new “Gossip Girl” artist. As is, the writing style needs work. Maybe, it needs more of a story with graphics rather than a comic book like story or more square boxes of plot progression? I do not know, but vastly improved. 3 out of 5 stars
13. The Artwork: The creative artwork in this story is breathtaking, but I would have liked to see more backdrops rather than plain backgrounds. I cannot draw to save my life, so I am really impressed with how the characters are created in this one. Plus, this is freehand with no digital manipulations, so it is original artwork, not the stuff you see in stores that are digitally redone. 4 out of 5 stars
14. Genre: This book is easily a graphic novel mixed with some fantasy and romance. It is a nice story to sit down with and only took me ten minutes to read through. This story id definitely for people who do not have much time on their hands to read, but still want to enjoy something and feel like they complete something as well. This is quick and allows one to feel accomplished that they have finished it. It is part of a series, so you can cram a chapter waiting at the doctor’s office or wherever one goes. I believe it deserves stars, because it is so broken up that a busy person can always finish and start the next chapter whenever, rather than only finishing part of a book. I get the satisfaction to have one book “read” on www.goodreads.com rather than only a percentage of it completed. 5 out of 5 stars
15. Title: I have a very legit question about the title. I noticed that it mentions that chapter one is entitled “The Bracelet” many times, but on the actual entrance into the book with graphics, it names that same chapter “The Curse”. So, I am confused. Is it “The Bracelet” or “The Curse”? This is a prime reason why Indie authors need an editor. An editor would easily catch this type of flaws, before they go into print or digital download. Otherwise than that, I believe that the title is suiting, although I am not into the series far enough to know what the “Ten Confessions” part of the title means. 2 out of 5 stars
Overall, I give this chapter 3 stars. It is very average, but it is only a chapter into the work itself. It has the potential to do better and add some much needed enrichment into the story. I kind of wish that there was an option to buy the story as a whole to give it a much more honest review rather than reading it in sections like this and reviewing each section. I think I am blowing it up a little, just because there is not much to go on. So, do not expect this to be long, but short and sweet. Any review after this one, will combine both chapters to give readers a more honest read on this series.
NOTE: THE FOLLOWING CATEGORIES HAVE BEEN CHANGED AS OF MARCH 28, 2013
15. Title: This issue has been resolved with the author. The titles are consistently Chapter One: The Bracelet. Due to this change, the stars have been changed. The title know holds a hint of mystery that is enough to entice the reader to wonder what is so special about a simple bracelet. 5 out of 5 stars
5. The Plot: The story is now not very predictable. The only predictable element is that the main character cannot see that her best friend loves her, which occurs in many stories. 4 out of 5 stars
8. Engaging Surprises: Since the title no longer reveals all, I believe that there are a couple of mystery surprises to add. 3 out of 5 stars
9. Climax: Now that the story is not revealed as much with the title, there is a bit of a climax, but not much since there still is not really enough story to really get invested into it. I think that as the chapters progress, this area will improve, because each chapter builds up onto itself. 2 out of 5 stars
I know all of these categories are out of order, but it makes sense to put number fifteen first due to the importance of the correction to this graphic novel. Now, with the new edits, I give this book 3.43 out of 5 stars. I would round it to 3.5 stars. It is an enjoyable read.